[2E] Consume

Rear Admiral Anmeldungsdatum: 06.01.2005 Beiträge: 776 Wohnort: Terok Nor

Was ist eigentlich wenn ich ein consume Dilemma bekomme und der Gegner hat keinen Dilemma Pile mehr und kann somit nicht konsumieren?

If you do not have enough cards in the dilemma pile you cannot play a dilemma with CONSUME keyword. CONSUME is a COST to play the dilemma.

dAgent i. R. Anmeldungsdatum: 10.01.2005 Beiträge: 191

No, this is not right! Although it works like an additional cost it is an effect of the dilemma. This means consuming dilemmas is no condition.

This is similar to the additional "cost" of many dissidents where you have to discard a card when playing them. It's also only an effect and having no cards do discard doesn't influence the playability of such a personnel.

JaglomShrek hat folgendes geschrieben:

No, this is not right! Although it works like an additional cost it is an effect of the dilemma. This means consuming dilemmas is no condition.

This is similar to the additional "cost" of many dissidents where you have to discard a card when playing them. It's also only an effect and having no cards do discard doesn't influence the playability of such a personnel.

I have red about it here
http://forums.fanhq.com/viewtopic.php?t=43585&highlight=consume

dAgent i. R. Anmeldungsdatum: 10.01.2005 Beiträge: 191

Here is the answer from that topic:

Zitat:

Consume isn't a cost. Costs in gametext are seen in the format "Do COST to do EFFECT." The reason Consume X can't consume more than you have is because the X is whatever actually is consumed, and you can't actually consume more than is left in your dilemma pile.

As for non-X consumes, if you have one dilemma left when your opponent faces In Training, you'll only consume the one remaining dilemma, but that falls under the way effects are handled, specifically: do as much as you can.

JaglomShrek hat folgendes geschrieben:

Here is the answer from that topic:

Zitat:

Consume isn't a cost. Costs in gametext are seen in the format "Do COST to do EFFECT." The reason Consume X can't consume more than you have is because the X is whatever actually is consumed, and you can't actually consume more than is left in your dilemma pile.

As for non-X consumes, if you have one dilemma left when your opponent faces In Training, you'll only consume the one remaining dilemma, but that falls under the way effects are handled, specifically: do as much as you can.

Well, I probably have mistaken this. IEl
If you have 1 dilemma in your dilemma pile
a) You can play CONSUME: 2
b) You can play CONSUME: X and say 1
c) You cannot play CONSUME: X and say 15